Is Well Water Safe to Drink? Risks, Tests and How to Make It Safe

Boreholeflow is reader supported. When you buy through links on this page, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

Quick answer
  • Well water can be perfectly safe to drink, but no one checks it except you. Private wells are not covered by the Safe Drinking Water Act.
  • In a USGS study of 2,100 private wells, about 1 in 5 had at least one contaminant above a health benchmark, mostly from natural sources.
  • The CDC says to test at least once a year for coliform bacteria, nitrate, pH and total dissolved solids, and after floods, repairs or changes in taste or smell.
  • Clear, good tasting water is not proof of safety. Arsenic, nitrate and bacteria have no taste or smell.

I drill and service wells for a living, and the question I hear most from new well owners is simple: can I drink this? The honest answer is that most well water is fine, but you only know after a lab test.

More than 43 million Americans drink from private wells, according to the USGS. City water is tested by law; your well is tested only when you pay for it.

This guide covers what can go wrong with well water, how to know if yours is safe, which tests to run and how to fix the common problems. Use the risk checker to see where to start.

Well water risk checker

Is my well water safe? Risk checker

Tick everything that applies to your well. We score the risk and list the tests and fixes to do first. This is a guide, not a lab result.

Why well water is different from city water

A city water system has to meet EPA limits and test on a schedule. A private well does not. The EPA says well owners are responsible for the safety of their own water.

That cuts both ways. Good well water has no chlorine, no fluoride added and no water bill. But if something gets into your aquifer or your well, nobody will warn you.

What can make well water unsafe

ContaminantWhere it comes fromHealth concernDetail
Coliform bacteria, E. coliSeptic systems, animals, floods, a damaged capStomach illnessColiform guide
NitrateFertilizer, manure, septicDangerous for babies under 6 monthsNitrate guide
ArsenicNatural rockCancer risk over many yearsArsenic guide
Radon and uraniumGranite and bedrockCancer riskRadon guide
LeadOld pipes, brass and solderHarm to children’s developmentLead guide
ManganeseNatural rock and soilNervous system effects at high levelsManganese guide
PFASFirefighting foam, landfills, industryLong term health effectsPFAS guide
Iron, sulfur, hardnessNatural rockMostly taste, stains and odourIron guide

The USGS found that metals, radionuclides and nitrate were the chemicals most often above health benchmarks, and all but nitrate come mainly from natural rock. Microbes were found in about a third of the wells it tested for them.

Warning signs your well water may be unsafe

  • Taste, colour or smell changes suddenly. Something has changed in the well or aquifer.
  • Cloudy or muddy water after heavy rain. Surface water may be getting in. See cloudy well water.
  • Stomach upsets in the family or guests. Bacteria is the usual suspect.
  • Flooding near the wellhead. Treat the water as unsafe until tested.
  • Damaged cap or casing, or a well that sits in a low spot.
  • Rotten egg smell or orange stains. Usually nuisance problems, but test anyway.

The most dangerous contaminants, like arsenic, nitrate and many bacteria, have no taste, smell or colour. Crystal clear water can still fail a lab test, which is why testing matters more than looks.

How to test your well water

The CDC recommends testing at least once a year for total coliform bacteria, nitrates, total dissolved solids and pH. Test more often if there are problems nearby, after flooding or repairs, if taste or smell changes, or when a baby or pregnant woman joins the home.

TestHow oftenWhy
Total coliform and E. coliEvery year, and after floods or repairsShows whether bacteria can get in
NitrateEvery yearCritical for babies
pH and TDSEvery yearShows corrosive or mineral heavy water
Arsenic, uranium, radonOnce, then every 3 to 5 yearsNatural rock contaminants
LeadOnce, then if plumbing changesOld pipes and fittings
Iron, manganese, hardness, sulfurWhen you plan treatmentSizes softeners and filters

A state certified lab gives the most reliable result. Your county health department can point you to one and tell you which local contaminants to add. A home kit is a useful first screen; see best well water test kits and how often to test well water.

See well water test kits on Amazon

What your well water results mean

ResultWhat it meansWhat to do
Coliform absentNo sign of bacteria entryTest again next year
Coliform present, E. coli absentA path for surface water existsShock the well, fix the cap, retest
E. coli presentFecal contaminationStop drinking it; boil or use bottled water; shock and find the source
Nitrate over 10 mg/LAbove the EPA limitDo not give to infants; treat with reverse osmosis
Arsenic over 10 ppbAbove the EPA limitPoint of use RO or an arsenic filter
pH below 6.5Acidic, can leach metalsAcid neutralizer; test lead and copper

EPA limits for public water systems, which are the usual benchmark for private wells.

How to make well water safe to drink

  1. Fix the well first. A sanitary cap, casing above ground and water draining away from the wellhead stop most bacteria problems. See best well caps.
  2. Shock chlorinate after a positive bacteria test or any repair. See how to shock a well.
  3. Add continuous disinfection if bacteria keeps coming back. A UV system is the usual choice; see UV purifiers for coliform.
  4. Use reverse osmosis at the kitchen tap for nitrate, arsenic, lead and PFAS. See under sink RO for well water.
  5. Treat nuisance problems with a softener, iron filter or sediment filter. See whole house filters for well water.
  6. Retest after any treatment to prove it works.

See UV purifiers on Amazon

Well water vs city water

Private wellCity water
Who tests itYouThe water utility, by law
ChlorineNone unless you add itYes
Monthly billNone (electricity for the pump)Yes
Common issuesBacteria, nitrate, natural metals, hardnessChlorine taste, old lead service lines
During a power cutNo water without backupUsually keeps flowing

Many well owners prefer the taste and independence of their own water. The trade off is that you are the water company. For outages, see well water without power.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe to drink well water?

It can be. Many wells give excellent water, but private wells are not regulated, and about 1 in 5 tested by the USGS had a contaminant above a health benchmark. A lab test is the only way to know.

How do I know if my well water is safe to drink?

Test it at a state certified lab at least once a year for coliform bacteria, nitrate, pH and total dissolved solids, plus any local contaminants your health department recommends.

Can you get sick from well water?

Yes. Bacteria such as E. coli can cause stomach illness, and nitrate is dangerous for babies. Long term exposure to arsenic, radon or uranium raises cancer risk.

Should I boil my well water?

Boiling kills bacteria, so it is the right step after a positive E. coli test or a flood. It does not remove nitrate, arsenic or lead, and boiling concentrates nitrate.

Is well water healthier than city water?

Neither is automatically healthier. Well water has no chlorine and may have natural minerals, but it is only as safe as your last test.

How often should I test my well water?

Every year for bacteria, nitrate, pH and TDS, and every few years for arsenic, uranium and radon. Test again after floods, repairs or any change in taste, colour or smell.

Can I drink well water after a flood?

No. Treat it as unsafe until the well is shock chlorinated and a lab test shows no coliform bacteria.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *