How to Replace a Well Pressure Switch (Step by Step)
Boreholeflow is reader supported. When you buy through links on this page, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
- Replace a pressure switch with one of the same range, such as 40/60 psi, and the same features, such as a low pressure cut off lever.
- Turn off the breaker and test the wires are dead, drain the system to zero psi, then photograph the wiring before you remove anything.
- Set the pressure tank air charge to 2 psi below the new cut in pressure while the tank is empty of water.
- Clear the small pipe nipple under the switch. A clogged nipple causes the same symptoms as a bad switch.
The pressure switch is the small grey box on the pipe near your pressure tank. It turns the pump on when pressure drops and off when it reaches the set point, thousands of times a year.
When the contacts burn or the diaphragm fails, the pump can refuse to start, refuse to stop or chatter on and off. This guide shows how to confirm the switch is the problem and replace it safely.
Signs of a bad pressure switch
| What you see | Could be the switch? | Also check |
|---|---|---|
| Pump will not start, but the breaker is on | Yes: burned or stuck contacts | Power at the switch, the control box and the pump |
| Pump will not stop | Yes: welded contacts or a clogged nipple | Low water in the well or a worn pump. See well pump will not shut off |
| Pump clicks on and off every few seconds | Sometimes | Most often a waterlogged pressure tank. See well pump short cycling |
| Chattering or buzzing at the switch | Yes: pitted contacts | A clogged nipple under the switch |
| Sparks or a burnt smell from the switch | Yes | Turn off the breaker now |
| Pressure never reaches the old cut out | Rarely | Pump wear, a leak or a well running low |
Before you buy a switch, rule out the pressure tank with signs of a bad pressure tank and check the settings in well pressure switch settings. A switch costs little, but replacing the wrong part wastes an afternoon.
Pressure switch and tank setting helper
Pressure switch and tank setting helper
Pick the switch range printed on your old switch. We show the matching replacement and the air charge your pressure tank needs.
Tools and parts
- A replacement switch with the same pressure range and features as the old one.
- A non contact voltage tester or multimeter.
- Two adjustable wrenches or pipe wrenches.
- Screwdrivers and a nut driver.
- Thread seal tape or pipe dope rated for potable water.
- A tire pressure gauge to check the tank air charge, and a small air compressor or bike pump.
- A short brass pipe nipple, in case the old one is clogged or corroded.
See 40/60 pressure switches on Amazon
How to replace a well pressure switch
- Turn off the breaker for the pump. Then test the wires at the switch with a voltage tester to confirm they are dead.
- Drain the pressure. Open a tap near the tank, or the drain valve under it, until the gauge reads zero.
- Remove the cover and take a clear photo of the wiring before you touch anything.
- Disconnect the wires. Label the line wires (from the breaker) and the load wires (to the pump), plus the ground.
- Loosen the cable clamps and slide the cables out of the switch.
- Unscrew the old switch from the pipe nipple, holding the fitting below with a second wrench so you do not twist the pipe.
- Clean or replace the nipple. Mineral scale and sediment in this small pipe often cause switch trouble.
- Seal and install the new switch. Wrap the threads with tape or use pipe dope, then thread the switch on until it is snug and upright.
- Reconnect the wires to match your photo and the diagram inside the new cover: line to line terminals, load to load terminals, ground to the green screw.
- Refit the cover and tighten its nut by hand.
The terminal layout differs between makers, so follow the diagram on the new switch rather than memory. Hunker’s Square D install guide and InspectAPedia’s switch replacement notes cover the same sequence.
Set the pressure tank air charge
With the pump off and the system drained to zero, check the air valve on top of the tank with a tire gauge. Set it to 2 psi below the cut in pressure: 38 psi for a 40/60 switch or 28 psi for a 30/50 switch.
A wrong air charge makes the pump cycle too often, which shortens the life of the new switch and the pump. If the valve spits water, the bladder has failed; see the best well pressure tanks.
See tire pressure gauges on Amazon
Test and adjust
- Close the tap you opened and turn the breaker back on.
- Watch the gauge. The pump should start right away and stop near the cut out pressure.
- Check the fittings for drips while the system is at full pressure.
- Open a tap and note where the pump restarts. It should be close to the cut in pressure.
- If the settings are off, turn off the power and adjust the nuts: the large spring changes both settings together, the small spring changes only the cut out.
Adjust in small steps, half a turn at a time, and never set a cut out higher than your pump can reach. Full adjustment steps are in well pressure switch settings.
When to call a pro
- You are not comfortable working with 230 volt wiring, or the wiring does not match any diagram.
- The new switch does not fix the problem, which points to the pump, the control box or the wiring.
- The breaker trips when the pump starts. See well pump keeps tripping the breaker.
- You want to upgrade to a constant pressure system. See constant pressure well pump systems.
Wondering what a full pump job costs instead? See well pump replacement cost.
Switch stopped working on a cold night? The small tube under the switch is often the first thing to freeze. Our frozen well pipes guide covers safe thawing, and heat tape keeps it from freezing again.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my well pressure switch is bad?
Common signs are a pump that will not start or will not stop, chattering or buzzing at the switch, and burned or pitted contacts. Rule out the pressure tank and a clogged nipple first.
Can I replace a 30/50 switch with a 40/60?
Yes, if your pump can reach 60 psi at your well depth. You also need to reset the tank air charge to 38 psi.
What should the pressure tank be set at?
Set the air charge to 2 psi below the cut in pressure with the tank empty of water. That is 38 psi for a 40/60 switch and 28 psi for a 30/50 switch.
How long does a well pressure switch last?
There is no fixed lifespan. Hard water, sediment and a waterlogged tank that makes the pump cycle often all wear the contacts out faster, so check the switch whenever pressure problems start.
What does the lever on a pressure switch do?
It is a low pressure cut off. It turns the pump off if pressure drops to about 10 psi, which protects the pump if the well runs dry or a pipe bursts.
Do I need an electrician to replace a pressure switch?
Many homeowners replace a like for like switch themselves. If you are not confident working with 230 volt wiring, hire a licensed electrician or pump service.






